Showing posts with label virginia. Show all posts
Showing posts with label virginia. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 10, 2009

More Discrimination in the Commonwealth

The great state (pardon me, commonwealth) of Virginia just can't stop coming up with discriminatory driving laws. First it was the "abusive driver fees," under which if you drove too fast you could get hit up for a "fee" of $1,050, on top of the normal $200 ticket, but only if you were from Virginia -- the fee wouldn't apply to out-of-staters who drove at the same speed. That got shot down as unconstitutional.

Now, Virginia's Senate has decided that drivers should be ticketed for using a cell phone while driving -- but only teenagers. The current rule is that teenage drivers are prohibited from using a cell phone while driving, but can be ticketed for it only if they are pulled over for another violation. Apparently there's no prohibtion against adults using cell phones while driving.

Look, if cell phone use while driving is dangerous, it's dangerous. I seriously doubt that 50-year-olds are handier with their cell phones than teenagers -- if anything, the reverse seems more likely. Teens are probably worse at driving in general, but whatever added danger is involved in cell phone use, I expect it applies to everybody. Virginia needs good safe driving laws, but they should apply fairly.

Friday, August 3, 2007

Home Town Call

Henrico County Judge Archer L. Yeatts III declared Virginia's new abusive driver fees unconstitutional, on the ground that the violate the Constitution's Equal Protection Clause because they apply only to Virginia residents, not drivers from out of state who commit the same violations.

Hmm, I can't find the decision on line, but I just don't see it. Suppose a state said, "the annual driver's license fee in this state depends on the number of points you have on your driver's license. It's $25 if you have no points, but then it's an extra $25 for each point you have."

Could there be anything wrong with that? The state's driver's license fee would apply, necessarily, only to people who sought a driver's license from that state. Out of staters wouldn't have to pay it. But so what? Could that possibly violate the Equal Protection Clause? I don't see how a state can be prevented from having a driver's license fee system that varies according to the proven tendency of each driver to violate the state's laws.

Well, I shouldn't really pass judgment without having seen the court's opinion, or even the actual underlying law. The right outcome could depend on exactly how Virginia has the fees set up, I suppose. But it certainly seems to me that Virginia could set up its fees to be perfectly constitutional, by just making them a condition of one's Virginia driver's license. Then they naturally would apply only to people in Virginia.

Tuesday, July 24, 2007

Virginia's Road Rage

Virginians keep getting more and more upset with the state's new "abusive driver fees," first reported by the Washington Post back in June. Under the new system, drivers convicted of certain traffic offenses will get hit up with an extra "fee" on top of the ordinary fine they're assessed by the judge. And the fees are hefty: if you drive more than 20 miles an hour over the speed limit, you'll pay the ordinary $200 fine and then get assessed a "fee" of $1,050 by the state. Quite an unhappy surprise.

And, oh, by the way, the fees apply only to Virginians -- out-of-state bad drivers don't have to pay them.

Since the fees were first reported by the Post they've led to a long series of articles about how upset Virginians are: first there was a report of a "growing backlash," then an "outcry" and a claim that some of the fees were "mistakes," then a petition for repeal that got over 100,000 signatures. The latest word is a report on the unintended consequences of similar fees in other states that have adopted them, such as an increase in unlicensed drivers (people who've had their licenses suspended because they can't afford to pay the fees), and a suggestion that the fees haven't done much to improve safety in those states.

The fundamental problem, I would say, is that once fees become detached from their original purpose, it's impossible to deal with them properly. The purpose of fines for speeding and other driving offenses should be to punish and deter bad driving. The fees should be set at a level sufficient to make people think twice about speeding or doing something else that's hazardous. The goal should be to improve safety on the roads.

It's clear, however, that the purpose of the new Virginia fees is to raise revenue. The fees originated as a substitute for a statewide tax increase. Once that becomes the goal, there's no stopping point. Why not charge speeders $5,000? And $10,000 for drivers running a red light?

Once fees become primarily about revenue, their ability to serve their original function can be greatly reduced. The best example, I think, is the rush-hour times on Washington's subway, the Metro. When I arrived in town, evening rush hour was defined as ending at 7 pm. In 1995, it was extended to 8 pm.

Now, that was ridiculous. The purpose of rush hour (during which the fares are higher) is to spread out passenger traffic by giving people an incentive to leave work later. Rush hour ending at 7 pm can do that with some success. But if rush hour goes until 8, the number of people willing to wait is going to decrease pretty sharply.

The obvious problem was that Metro's board had detached rush hour from its purpose. They didn't extend it until 8 because that made sense in terms of spreading out passenger traffic; they just needed more money, and so they decided to hit up more riders -- basically, almost all the commuters -- for the rush hour fares. But once they did that, rush hour couldn't serve its function of spreading out passengers, because people wouldn't want to wait until 8. I presume the trains got a lot more crowded from 5:30 - 6:30, as the people who used to wait until 7 just went home when they really wanted to. Today, the rush hour fare (officially known as the "regular fare," isn't that nice) has returned to its more sensible 7 pm ending time.

Virginia will, doubtless, experience a similar fate if it keeps its "abusive driver" fees. They may sound like a safety measure, but so long as they are really a revenue measure, I doubt they will be set at a level that will best serve the safety function. They'll be too high, they will have unintended consequences, and you'll see a lot of unsmiling Virginians on the roads.