Showing posts with label bush. Show all posts
Showing posts with label bush. Show all posts

Friday, May 16, 2008

No Appeasement

I got into a furious debate last night with someone who couldn't stop talking about how Barack Obama will destroy America. I was bearing his tirade patiently until he got to talking about how wrong the left-wing media was to jump on President Bush's righteous suggestion that those who advocate holding diplomatic talks with heads of nations we won't currently talk to, such as Iran and North Korea, are promoting appeasement.

Bush's comparison is inapt. The appeasement of Hitler by western powers -- to which Bush specifically compared suggestions that we talk to Iran or North Korea -- didn't consist of talking to Hitler; it consisted of giving him the Sudetenland and acquiescing in his other conquests. There's a big difference between holding diplomatic talks and giving in to territorial demands.

Diplomatic talks don't have to be weak. They can be tough too. We talked to the Soviet Union throughout the Cold War. That didn't mean we appeased it.

I'm not expert enough to say whether holding talks with Iran or North Korea would work better than the current strategy -- although the current strategy does seem like a disaster. But I do know that calling anyone who disagrees with you an appeaser is cheap claptrap.

Sunday, February 17, 2008

Feeling Less Safe?

The Protect America Act expired yesterday, after the House of Representatives went on recess without passing a Senate-approved version of new amendments to the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act.

For those new to the story, Congress passed the PAA last summer after the Bush administration claimed that it needed new wiretapping authority to protect against terrorist threats. Because the PAA was intrusive on civil liberties, Congress included a sunset provision that made the act expire after six months, during which Congress hoped to work out a better version.

Intense wrangling over the better version developed, particularly with regard to the question of whether telecom companies should be immune from suit for complying with administration data request -- or, to put it less politely, for spying on their customers. The Senate said yes, but the House version of the bill hadn't included such immunity.

As usual, President Bush forecasts dire danger to U.S. security if the Congress doesn't give him all the surveillance power he wants. But for a change, the House refused to cave in to the President's fear mongering.

It's about time someone stood up to the President on this issue. I'm all for protecting America from terrorism, but civil liberties matter too, and the President can't expect to have everything his own way. His uncompromising approach is just as responsible for any security risk that we're now facing as any Democratic desires. Congress offered another temporary extension of the PAA while things got worked out, but the President refused.

With the PAA's authority expired, the administration will need to get judicial approval for wiretapping more often. Is that a major security hazard? I'm having trouble seeing it.

Tuesday, January 29, 2008

Those Hidden Earmarks

Here's an interesting tidbit that may not have sprung out at you as you dutifully watched President Bush's State of the Union address last night: the President said that he will, today, issue an executive order instructing federal agencies to ignore earmarks that aren't actually included in legislation.

The sound you hear is wailing, gnashing of teeth, and hell generally breaking loose on capitol hill. If the President gets away with this, it will be a big change in how things get done.

Of course, the real mystery is how earmarks have survived so long without being legislated. The way things have traditionally worked, it often happens that the actual text of appropriations legislation just specifies a lump sum for a general activity, and the "earmark" of a particular amount for something like a bridge to nowhere is included, not in the text of the law, but in a committee report accompanying the law.

Committee reports are not actually binding. The law is binding. Why do agencies follow committee reports at all? Presumably, they're afraid of what will happen to them the following year if they don't do what the committee wanted. But the executive officially answers to the law, not to a committee.

So I would say the President is on solid legal ground on this one. But politically, he's asking for more trouble than Bill Clinton could cause in a whole room full of White House interns. Considering what a low political ebb Bush is at, I'm surprised he's taking it on.

Monday, January 28, 2008

A Year to Go

President Bush makes his last State of the Union address tonight. We have one year left -- actually a bit less, 358 days -- before we finally get someone, anyone, other than this Bush as our President.

Look at our military. It's hard to believe now that Bush ran for office on a campaign that claimed that President Clinton had destroyed the military at that he would rebuild it. What's happened over the last seven years? Even Bush's most ardent supporters would have to agree that the military has been stretched to the breaking point by Bush's military adventures.

Look at our international standing. The day after 9/11, Le Monde captured world sentiment by proclaiming "we are all Americans." The President had a unique opportunity to build on international good will. Today, the world looks at America with apprehension and suspicion.

Look at our pocketbooks. After seven years of Bush's "pro-business", "ownership society" policies, the S&P 500 Index is slightly lower than it was the day he took office. Remember, the typical growth of the index is about 10% per year. Over seven years, it should be up about 95%. In eight years of the Clinton presidency, it was up 208.5%. Instead, our retirement portfolios are unchanged over seven years and we can look forward to working longer before we can retire.

The list could go on. But boy, I am sure ready for a different President. A year to wait.

Monday, January 7, 2008

Wall Street Review

Sorry for the lack of blogging last week; I was away at the AALS Conference of law professors.

As the trading year begins for 2008, I thought I'd do a brief check-in on Wall Street. Our illustrious president, you will recall, has spent years promoting the "ownership society," featuring, among other things, "Expanding Ownership of Retirement Assets." The message, I take it, is that we're all supposed to keep an eye on our investment portfolios and thank the Republicans for their business-friendly policies that will pump up our returns.

The result? Well, as I write, the S&P 500 index is at 1414 and the Nasdaq Composite index is at 2498. On the day President Bush took office, they were at 1342 and 2770, respectively. Thus, under our business-friendly, owernship-society, Republican President, the S&P is up 5.3% over seven years and the Nasdaq is down 9.8%.

Meanwhile, under the presidency of those left-wing, business-hating, over-regulating, squash-the-economy Democrats, the S&P 500 went up 208.5% and the Nasdaq went up 297.6%, from 1993-2001. And yes, there was some tech bubble in those figures, but, if you will recall, the bubble burst in March 2000, so those are really the post-bubble totals.

Sheesh. All that work by Republicans to make the rich richer, and those of us in S&P 500 index funds would have done far better with T-bills. And that's over seven years. Seven years of investments going nowhere, and we haven't even seen the full fallout of the housing bubble burst. Could we bring back the Democrats, please?

Wednesday, January 2, 2008

Pro Forma Redux

Once again the Senate is engaging in pro forma sessions every three days, in order to thwart President Bush's ability to make recess appointments. Apparently Senator Jim Webb of Virginia, who's now presided over such sessions several times, has the thing down to 10 seconds.

As I mentioned before, there's a reasonable argument that the President's recess appointment power doesn't apply during intrasession recesses anyway: the Constitution says that the President can make a recess appointment during "the recess" of the Senate, not during "a recess" of the Senate. The definite article "the" suggests that the Framers were thinking about the recess that occurs between Senate sessions, not just any old recess, such as the one that occurs every day when the Senate goes to lunch. Indeed, that was the understanding of the Recess Appointment Clause explicitly announced by Attorney General Philander Knox in 1901.

But this point inevitably makes one think about the upcoming intersession recess. At some point, the Senate has to end its current session and start its new session. That's currently scheduled to occur on January 22. Even assuming the Senate holds one last pro forma meeting as part of its current session on that very day, there will have to be at least a moment when the Senate is between the two sessions.

Not enough time for mischief, you say? You underestimate the mischievous minds of Presidents. On December 7, 1903, when Teddy Roosevelt was President (and when the recess appointment power was understood to apply only during intercession recesses), the Senate was in a special session called by the President on November 9. At some point on December 7, the Presiding officer banged the gavel to end the special session and then immediately banged it again to start the new, regular session. And President Roosevelt later announced that in the instant between the two gavel bangs, when the Senate was in a genuine, bona fide, but very brief intercession recess, he had made 160 recess appointments!

If President Teddy Roosevelt was ready to play games like that, just imagine what President Bush would do.

Sunday, December 9, 2007

Straining at the Gnat

Yesterday, we took a day off from relentless critique to admit an error of our own. We now return to our regularly scheduled programming.

I don't pretend to understand the national budget, but I do know that President Bush has been one of our most profligate, extravagant spenders ever. The Republicans talked about reining in federal spending for decades, but from 2000 to 2004, when they had control of the White House and both houses of Congress, federal spending increased at twice the rate it had increased under President Clinton (and that's straight from Fox News).

But now, even though Congress looks like it will cave in once again and give him $70 billion in Iraq war funding with no strings attached, President Bush is threatening to veto the omnibus budget bill because it contains $11 billion in domestic spending he doesn't want. Heavens, Bush proposed $623 billion in defense spending alone; he wants to spend almost $3 billion in Iraq and Afghanistan every week, and he can't compromise on $11 billion in domestic spending he doesn't like? We've got $141 billion to spend in Iraq and Afghanistan but not $11 billion to spend at home?

Look, I don't know the details. Maybe there's something specially bad about this $11 billion. But for Bush and the Republicans to claim that they've suddenly discovered fiscal responsibility is absurd. They've been pouring our money down bottomless foreign pits for five years now. They boosted domestic spending to record highs when they controlled the whole show. Now the Dems have Congress and they're going to have to compromise a little.

Wednesday, November 14, 2007

The Great Bridge Scandal of 2007

Quite a story roiling the bridge world: the U.S. women's bridge team, winners of the of Venice Cup, the international women's world bridge championships, held up a sign saying "We did not vote for Bush" at the gold medal ceremony in Shanghai, during the playing the U.S. national anthem. The United States Bridge Federation, the organization that represents the U.S. in international play, wants to ban the winning team from play (including not just USBF play but American Contract Bridge League play as well) for a year. The story has already made the N.Y. Times and of course it's all the rage on the bridge newsgroup.

A little analysis: it's not actually a First Amendment matter, because there's no government involvement. The USBF is a private organization. The NFL bans players from displaying political messages during games and that doesn't violate the First Amendment. So while it seems reflexive (to Americans) to invoke the First Amendment, that's not actually the issue.

No, the issue is whether the penalty makes any sense. I do think the players were naive to imagine that people wouldn't get offended. Injecting politics into a bridge event is naturally going to raise some hackles. We all know what happened to the Dixie Chicks when they mixed an offhand political comment with music -- and that was at their own concert. And of course the 1968 Olympic incident involving Tommie Smith and John Carlos is an even closer parallel. So the team should have known they were asking for trouble.

Still, the penalty seems way over the top. It's not clear, first of all, that the USBF actually has any rule that was violated; the Federation seems to be proceeding under a general rule forbidding "conduct unbecoming a player." That's a bit of a stretch. Second, the USBF's authority to ban players from ACBL play seems mysterious. Finally, the penatly just seems far too harsh. Players may not have a right to express political messages at the awards ceremony, but, being Americans, we should let free speech be a value that informs how harshly we treat it. What kind of message are we sending to the Chinese hosts of the game with such a harsh penalty? "Yes, stamping out dissenting political messages is a great thing"?

Probably what's happening is that the UCBF is run by a bunch of humorless Republicans who can't bear to see Bush criticized and who are flexing their muscles. If I were in charge, I would give the players a talking-to and institute a rule of decorum for awards ceremonies. The players can make whatever statement they want afterwards. But for this incident, let's chill a little.

Thursday, August 30, 2007

Easy Act to Follow

As President Bush thinks about replacing AGAG, he needs to find someone of unimpeachable stature, who could get 90 votes in the Senate without breathing hard and who'd run the Department in a way that would make everyone proud.

It's so obvious. But will he do it? If past performance is any indicator of future results, in the end he'll choose someone who'll just be even more controversial and who'll have us yearning for the old days of Ashcroft and Gonzales.

It's a comfort to read that, for once, Bush is at least trying to think about finding a highly qualified candidate. But we'll see if he can come up with one who'd be willing to take the job.

Monday, August 6, 2007

Guns Gone Astray

It's become a cliche that the Bush Administration is so intent on vindicating the conservative belief that government is incompetent that it almost seems to screw things up deliberately. But really, this is too much. Of the 355,000 pistols and AK-47 rifles that the U.S. has distributed to Iraqi forces, 190,000 are missing, according to a new GAO report. Pentagon officials "really have no idea where they are." Hmmm, could they be in the hands of the insurgents who are fighting us?

I'm sure it's not easy keeping track of things amid the hubbub of war. But the GAO found no problems accounting for weapons distributed to the Bosnian Federation Army during the Bosnian conflict. So it's not impossible to do these things properly. But one has to believe that a government intent on proving that government is bad is more likely to do a bad job.

And by the way, who was in charge of security training during the period when, according to GAO, "distribution was haphazard and rushed and failed to follow established procedures"? None other than Gen. David H. Petraeus, who's now in charge of the whole shooting match. Let's hope he's keeping better track of things now.

Wednesday, July 11, 2007

The Surgeon General Speaks Out

I complained previously that President Bush's stem cell decisions seemed to be driven by politics, not public health concerns. It turns out that someone else shares my view -- and it's only Bush's own former Surgeon General.

Richard H. Carmona, Surgeon General form 2002 to 2006, says that the Bush Administration "routinely" screened his speeches for political sensitivity and prevented him from speaking out on public health issues for politicial -- and even theological -- reasons. Carmona was blocked on the basis of what he called "preconceived beliefs that were scientifically incorrect."

The Bush Administration has long had a reputation for muzzling its own scientists for political reasons. Now one of Bush's own top political appointees confirms this practice.

The Bush response? You know, of course, that the White House will try to blame and discredit Dr. Carmona. But even knowing that in advance, the chutzpah of White House spokesman Tony Fratto takes one's breath away. He said: "As surgeon general, Dr. Carmona was given the authority and had the obligation to be the leading voice for the health of all Americans. It's disappointing to us if he failed to use his position to the fullest extent in advocating for policies he thought were in the best interests of the nation."

First muzzle him, then blame him for being muzzled.

Wednesday, June 13, 2007

This Afternoon

I've been imagining that my feeling that it would be best to close our extraordinary prison in Guantanamo Bay just reflects my profound ignorance of military and international security matters. Sure, it seems from my naive, uninformed viewpoint that, even assuming we put aside all questions about legality and just ruthlessly follow our national interests, Guantanamo's negative impact on our national values and international standing outweigh whatever advantage we get from keeping people we regard as terrorists or enemy combatants in a law-free, judge-proof, indefinite limbo. But what do I know? An important part of being a professor and a scholar is recognizing and admitting the limits of one's knowledge and information. I'm not in a good position to assess what Guantanamo is doing for us security-wise, and, for all I know, it really is helping a lot, maybe even so much that we should accept the negative consequences.

That's why I was so interested to see that Colin Powell says that if he were in charge he would close Guantanamo "this afternoon." Powell is in a position to weigh the costs and benefits of Guantanamo -- he's probably the most qualified person around. He's been a General, the National Security Advisor, Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, and Secretary of State. If there's someone who's in a better position to assess how Guantanamo is helping and hurting us with regard to our military, national security, and diplomatic needs, and to weigh these all up against each other, I'd like to know who it is. And he says he would close Guantanamo because it has become a major problem in "the way the world perceives America."

So maybe the liberals are right after all. Getting your way internationally is not just a matter of flexing your military muscles in every super-macho way you want. Paying a little attention to diplomacy and international law actually helps too. It's not just me saying this, it's Colin Powell.

And while we're at it, here are a few other things the President could do this afternoon:

  • Fire Alberto Gonzales and install an Attorney General who will enforce the laws honestly and impartially.
  • Fire Lurita Doan and instruct all appointees who serve at his pleasure that government departments are not to be politicized.
  • Admit that if we knew then what we know now, we would not have invaded Iraq.
  • Apologize for his role in taking the nation into war based on incorrect information.
  • Say that, however mistaken going into Iraq may have been in the first place, we're there now and we have to deal with the situation, come up with a truly credible plan for making Iraq succeed in a plausible time frame even though it will require sacrifices, and then implement the plan.

I know it's a little late in the Bush presidency and people are saying he's in his lame duck period, but wouldn't it be quite a jump-start if he admitted his past errors, swept the slate clean, and tried to do the right thing from here on out?

Wednesday, June 6, 2007

Scooter on Ice

So Lewis "Scooter" Libby gets a 30-month sentence for perjury, obstruction of justice, and lying to FBI investigators. Sentences don't sound so bad when stated in months, but that is two and a half years -- quite a stretch in the Big House. Now President Bush has to decide whether to pardon him.

I'm sticking with my prediction that the pardon will come on November 5, 2008 -- that's the day after the 2008 election, when Bush can issue the pardon with no fear of political consequences. But meantime, the conservative press is sounding the drumbeat for a pardon now.

You have to hand it to those conservatives: they display a perfect ability to argue without any embarrassment at contradicting what they've argued in the past. The National Review editorial argues that there is "solid justification for a pardon" because there was never a charge on the underlying act of outing a CIA agent (which the scandal was really about) but only charges of perjury and obstruction of justice.

Excuse me? Didn't the Republicans impeach President Clinton -- making about the biggest stink one can make in our country -- for perjury before a grand jury, even though the original investigation into Whitewater never amounted to anything? I don't recall the National Review coming to Clinton's defense then.

Displaying the same fine sensibilities, House Republicans are calling for the expulsion of indicted Democratic representative William Jefferson, even though they didn't try to expel Republicans Tom DeLay or Robert Ney when they were indicted.

The best way to deal with high-profile cases is by the numbers. Let's apply the usual rules. Libby was found guilty and received a sentence. I think I would have given him about 18 months, but the judge said 30. Extraordinary measures are unwarranted.

Wednesday, May 16, 2007

Shameless

Who's running the Department of Justice? A man who was so eager to get reauthorization for a wiretapping program that the Department had determined was illegal that he went to the hospital room of ailing Attorney General John Ashcroft to try to get him to overrule the decision of his Deputy (and Acting Attorney General) James Comey.

The Ashcroft Justice Department was not exactly known for its respect for legal niceties. Let's not forget that this same Department issued the infamous 2002 "torture memo" that not only provided the narrowest possible definition of "torture" ("intense pain or suffering . . . equivalent to the pain . . . associated with . . . death, organ failure, or permanent damage resulting in a loss of significant body function") but also, incredibly, suggested that the anti-torture statute unconstitutionally infringed on the President's Commander-in-Chief power without even mentioning Congress's military powers in its analysis. These guys would say anything to justify what the President wanted. When they conclude that your wiretapping program is illegal, you'd better listen.

Instead of listening, Alberto Gonzales, then White House Counsel, went to John Ashcroft's hospital room. Ashcroft had been hospitalilzed with gallstone pancreatitis and was in GWU Hopsital's ICU, and he had transferred the powers of the Attorney General to his deputy, Comey. The two had agreed that they could not certify the wiretapping program's legality. When Comey told the White House, Gonzales and White House Chief of Staff Andy Card went to Ashcroft's hospital bed with legal papers.

Bless Ashcroft's ailing heart. I never had much respect for him, but in this supreme crisis, when he was so ill he was in the intensive care unit, he not only turned down the White House Counsel and Chief of Staff and explained why they were wrong, but pointed at Comey and said, "But that doesn't matter, because I'm not the attorney general. There is the attorney general." Gonzales and Card left and Card later claimed that they had just been there to wish Ashcroft well!

It's hard to think of anything so shameless since Newt Gingrich went to his wife's hospital bed to work on their divorce.

And Alberto Gonzales, the man who was so eager to violate our rights that he went to the hospital to try to get an ailing Ashcroft to overrule his Deputy and Office of Legal Counsel, is now Attorney General of the United States. No wonder the whole Department is on life support.

Sunday, April 29, 2007

It's Confirmed

Just in case you were wondering whether the Bush Administration led us into war in Iraq based on rumors and exaggerations, sexed-up intelligence, and a pre-existing desire to take out Saddam rather than a belief that he represented an imminent threat, it's now confirmed by none other than former CIA Director and Medal of Freedom recipient George Tenet.

Tenet's new book asserts that "There was never a serious debate that I know of within the administration about the imminence of the Iraq threat," that "White House and Pentagon officials, and particularly Vice President Cheney, were determined to attack Iraq from the first days of the Bush administration, long before Sept. 11, 2001," and that there were "numerous efforts by aides to Cheney and then-Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld to insert 'crap' into public justifications for the war," including a speech by Cheney in August 2002 that "went well beyond what our analysis could support."

The Bush Administration's response is that there was a lot of wrestling with all the very serious questions leading up to the war, but that "the former CIA director might have been unaware of all the discussions. " That makes sense. If you're going to discuss questions of war and peace that turn critically on the quality of foreign intelligence, the last person you'd want in the room would be the CIA Director.

Of course, Tenet has his own axe to grind and so he may not be the most credible of sources, especially having presided over perhaps the two most disastrous intelligence failures in U.S. history -- failing to detect the 9/11 plot and telling us that Saddam was developing weapons of mass destruction. But even the Administration's own former fair-haired boy is now telling us that the Administration deliberately led us into war based on overhyped intelligence.

Monday, April 16, 2007

General Won't Serve as Czar

Everyone should read this: a retired Marine Corps general's explanation of why he won't serve as the "White House implementation manager," or War Czar, for the Iraq and Afghanistan wars. Basically, he refused to take the job because he determined that the Administration has no strategy for winning the war.

I assume Marine Corps generals are not a bunch of bleeding-heart liberals eager to bash the administration. So when one of them says that "that there is no agreed-upon strategic view of the Iraq problem or the region," that "We cannot 'shorthand' this issue with concepts such as the 'democratization of the region' or the constant refrain by a small but powerful group that we are going to 'win,' even as 'victory' is not defined or is frequently redefined," and that "We got it right during the early days of Afghanistan -- and then lost focus. We have never gotten it right in Iraq," it's important to listen.

I have no idea what the solution is in Iraq. Even if one believes that starting the war was an enormous mistake, we can't wave a wand and make it unhappen. Planning for the future has to start with a recognition of where we are now. We may need to accept some sacrifices to marshal the resources that would be needed to succeed. But we're never going to succeed with a strategy that amounts to tinkering at the margins with what we've been doing unsuccessfully for four years in the hope that we can somehow muddle through. The President says that Iraq is the central front in the war on terror -- the most important fight in the world. If he's serious, then it's up to him to make sure we win. When even the generals basically say that he's just muddling through, we have a right to be angry.

Thursday, March 29, 2007

Watch Doan's Memory at Work

If you'd like to see Lurita Doan try to explain what Scott Jennings was doing at GSA with slides about the 2008 elections, you can do so here.

Worth watching. It's particularly amusing to see Doan deny that a reasonable interpretation of the slide headed "2008 House Targets: Top 20" was that it was a political attempt to try to target the top 20 Democratic candidates for defeat in 2008. She says no, "I would say that this is a slide that says '2008 House Targets: Top 20.'" (Watch from 6:40 left.) Sheesh.

She can't remember the meeting, she can't remember what she said at the meeting, she can't explain what these slides have to do with GSA's core mission of managing government buildings.

It sure seems like a clear use of government offices for political campaign purposes.

Wanted: Managers with Bad Memories

Obviously, a major criterion for working in the Bush Administration is having a bad memory. Lurita Alexis Doan, the Administrator of the General Services Administration (which manages the federal government's buildings), says she can't remember much of what happened at a meeting just two months ago, this January 26.

At the meeting, Scott Jennings, a top aide to Karl Rove, gave a PowerPoint presentation on highly political topics, such as which were the White House's top 20 2008 House targets (i.e., House seats they hope to pick up in 2008). Doan says she "honestly do[es]n't have recollection of the presentation at all." According to others present at the meeting, Doan asked her top staffers "How can we use GSA to help our candidates in the next election?" When asked whether she said that, her response was, "I do not have a recollection of actually saying that."

No recollection? Wouldn't you remember, yes or no, whether you made a statement like that? It's a little different from "pass the mustard," I would say.

By saying that she "has no recollection" of making the statement, Doan is saying that she might have said it. She can't tell us that she didn't say it. It would have been more comforting, wouldn't you think, if she had said, "Well of course I would never have said such a thing because it would have been completely inappropriate to suggest that we 'use' a government agency to support 'our' candidates."

So let's see. Doan can't remember whether or not she blatantly politicized the GSA. Alberto Gonzales can't remember being involved in the U.S. Attorney firings -- or, more precisely, "doesn't recall having a recollection about having deliberative discussions," according to stand-in spokesperson Dana Perino. President Bush himself also "has no recollection" of suggesting the firings, although "anything's possible," according to Tony Snow. And of course Scooter Libby's memory has more holes than a Swiss cheese.

Can't anybody in this administration remember anything? Perhaps they're just very good at understanding which things are best forgotten.

Tuesday, March 27, 2007

OK, Now I'm Suspicious

Monica Goodling, senior counselor to Attorney General Alberto Gonzales, will refuse to testify before Congress about the firing of U.S. Attorneys. She's going to invoke her Fifth Amendment privilege against self-incrimination. She and her lawyers have prepared an affidavit and an explanation that claims that invocation of the privilege is appropriate, because Democrats in the Senate have already concluded that wrongdoing occurred in the U.S. Attorneys flap.

Hmm. Goodling and her counsel have cited a case, Ohio v. Reiner, 532 U.S. 17 (2001), which they claim supports her invocation of the Fifth Amendment privilege in this situation. In that case, a man was being prosecuted for manslaughter in connection with the death of his son, who had died of "shaken baby" syndrome. He claimed it was the babysitter who did it, and the babysitter refused to testify, even though she claimed complete innocence. The Supreme Court upheld the invocation of the privilege by someone claiming innocence, because part of the purpose of the privilege, the Court said, is to protect innocent people who "otherwise might be ensnared by ambiguous circumstances."

So I guess there is some basis for claiming the privilege here. Still, the case seems somewhat different. According to her counsel's own letter, one fear that Goodling has is that she might get prosecuted for perjury after testifying. And to be fair, in the current polarized political world, I can certainly understand the desire of a political official not to appear before a hostile Congress under oath. But still, I don't think the purpose of the privilege against self-incrimination is to protect people from having to testify truthfully. "I can't testify because I might lie" is not a very appetizing claim.

Even more important, the invocation of the privilege is highly suspicious. As I've said all along, the whole key to the U.S. Attorney "scandal" is why the fired U.S. Attorneys were fired. Even showing that the firings were "political" is not necessarily scandalous because some "political" reasons -- e.g., if the U.S. weren't fully on board with the administrations enforcement priorities -- would be perfectly appropriate reasons for the firing. Only if the reasons were "political" in a bad sense -- e.g., if the U.S. Attorneys were fired because they refused to stir up trouble for Democrats without regard to the evidence -- would there be a real scandal.

So what we need is evidence of why the firings really took place. And one probative piece of evidence is all the changes and contradictions in the administration's story. If the firings were done for a perfectly legitimate reason, why can't the administration just state that reason and be proud of it? Why does the White House keep changing its story? Did Attorney General Gonzales participate in the firing discussions, or didn't he? The changes and contradictions are suspicious.

Invocation of the Fifth Amendment is all of a piece with these suspicious circumstances. Outside the actual criminal contest, when a witness takes the Fifth, one is allowed to draw an adverse inference. If Goodling has to take the Fifth rather than testify, that raises the likelihood that the U.S. Attorneys were fired for some shameful reason. Can't the White House see that this kind of thing is just adding to its self-inflicted wounds on the U.S. Attorney issue?

Monday, March 19, 2007

U.S. Attorney Explanations Continue

I explained yesterday that whether the U.S. Attorney scandal is really a scandal turns on the reason for the firings -- some potential reasons are perfectly legitimate; others would be scandalous. Today's news -- that fired U.S. Attorney Carol Lam notified the White House of a major step in her investigation of well-connected defense contractors one day before Alberto Gonzales's chief of staff Kyle Sampson wrote an e-mail saying there was a "real problem" with her -- hints at the sinister explanation, although frankly, it's not as probative as one might think. I expect that there were so many steps involved in these firings, and U.S. Attorneys always have so much going on, that some temporal connection between something a U.S. Attorney did and a step in a firing would be expected by coincidence.

More probative, to me, is the fact that the White House keeps changing its story about what happened. If there was a legitimate reason for these firings, it shouldn't be that hard to state it. Continually changing explanations suggest a cover-up.

They also suggest, to me at least, that this isn't a Karl Rove operation. If Rove were in charge, you know he would have knocked this out of the park right away. He would have said something like, "the fired U.S. Attorneys weren't cooperating with our immigration enforcement policy. Do they really suppor the war on terrorism? We can't afford to have U.S. Attorneys who are squishy on terrorism. 9/11 changed everything, you know."